
Marriage is for the people in it: Part 1
Why protecting marriage must begin with caring for the husband and wife
Christians rightly place a high value on marriage. We believe that marriage is intended to be a lifelong commitment, that husbands and wives have responsibilities towards one another, and that difficulties should not become an excuse to abandon those responsibilities.
But in our determination to uphold marriage, we can sometimes lose sight of the people for whom God established it.
A marriage can continue in name while one of the people within it suffers terribly. A husband and wife may still live under the same roof, attend the same ecclesia and present themselves publicly as a married couple, while their private life bears little resemblance to the relationship God intended.
If we measure the success of a marriage principally by whether the couple remains together, we risk overlooking what is happening to the husband and wife themselves.
God’s concern is not simply that a marriage continues. He is concerned with how the people within it treat one another.
Marriage was established for our good
When God said, ‘It is not good that the man should be alone’ (Genesis 2:18), he identified a human need. Marriage was established to provide companionship and mutual help.
Husband and wife are given the opportunity to share their lives, support one another through difficulty, enjoy companionship and affection, and help each other grow in faithfulness to God.
The New Testament develops this understanding.
Paul calls husbands to love their wives as Christ loved the ecclesia, giving himself for her. He tells husbands to nourish and cherish their wives as they would their own bodies (Ephesians 5:25–29).
Peter instructs husbands to live with their wives with understanding and honour, reminding them that husband and wife are ‘heirs together of the grace of life’ (1 Peter 3:7).
This is a remarkable description of marriage. The husband and wife share something greater than the marriage itself: their relationship with God and their hope of eternal life.
Marriage belongs to our present life. Our hope in Christ reaches beyond it. Neither husband nor wife exists simply to serve the institution of marriage. Their marriage should help them serve God and care for one another.
Marital responsibilities are mutual
In 1 Corinthians 7:3–5, Paul describes the responsibilities of husband and wife towards each other, including their sexual relationship.
His language is strikingly mutual. The husband has obligations towards his wife, and the wife has obligations towards her husband. Neither is presented as having unrestricted authority over the other.
These responsibilities belong within the wider scriptural teaching about love, honour and care.
A husband’s responsibility to his wife cannot be separated from Christ’s example of self-giving love. Nor can a wife’s responsibilities be understood as granting her husband permission to intimidate, humiliate, coerce or harm her.
Sexual intimacy, for example, is intended to be an expression of mutual affection and care. It cannot faithfully fulfil that purpose when one spouse uses marital duty to demand sexual access against the other’s will.
A responsibility to love cannot become a right to demand submission to abuse.
The same principle applies to the wider marriage relationship. Providing financially, maintaining a household or remaining physically present does not excuse cruelty, intimidation or control.
Marriage requires faithful conduct, not simply the continuation of a married status.
What does it mean to protect a marriage?
Suppose a wife has endured years of intimidation, humiliation and coercive control. She eventually leaves the family home because she can no longer live safely with her husband.
Who has failed to honour the marriage?
It may be tempting to focus on the person who physically departed. After all, the couple is now separated, and the wife was the one who left.
But this overlooks what happened before she walked out of the door.
Her husband may have already rejected the responsibilities that should have made their home a place of love, security and care. His behaviour may have destroyed the conditions in which their marriage could be faithfully lived.
We should not overlook his conduct and then treat her departure as the decisive act of unfaithfulness.
There is an important distinction between leaving a home and abandoning the responsibilities of marriage.
This does not mean that every serious disagreement, failure or disappointment amounts to abandonment. Marriage requires patience, forgiveness and a willingness to work through difficulties. People make mistakes, sometimes serious ones, and repentance and change remain possible.
Persistent abuse is different. When a spouse repeatedly uses fear, coercion or cruelty to dominate the other, the marriage itself is being seriously violated.
Protecting marriage must include protecting the person being harmed.
God has called us to peace
Paul addresses marriage between believers and unbelievers in 1 Corinthians 7:12–16.
He does not teach that a difference in religious belief is sufficient reason to end a marriage. Where an unbelieving spouse is willing to continue the marriage, the believing spouse should not divorce simply because of that difference.
But Paul also recognises that one person cannot sustain a marriage alone.
Where the unbelieving spouse departs, Paul says that the brother or sister is ‘not enslaved’, adding that ‘God has called you to peace’ (1 Corinthians 7:15).
Paul is addressing departure by an unbelieving spouse, not expressly describing domestic abuse. Nevertheless, his teaching recognises a limit to what one spouse can be expected to do when the other repudiates the marriage relationship.
We believe this principle is relevant where grave, persistent abuse has effectively repudiated the responsibilities of marriage, even though the abusive spouse remains physically present.
A husband who remains in the house while terrorising his wife cannot establish his faithfulness simply by pointing to his physical presence. His insistence that she remain with him is not evidence that he is willing to live with her in the manner Scripture requires.
Nor should religious profession conceal the contradiction between belief and conduct.
Paul warns that someone who fails to provide for their household has denied the faith (1 Timothy 5:8). Titus 1:16 describes people who profess to know God but deny him by their works.
These passages do not automatically classify an abusive professing believer as the unbelieving spouse described in 1 Corinthians 7. They do remind us that professed faith must be considered alongside conduct.
A person’s attendance at meetings, knowledge of Scripture or respected ecclesial position cannot cancel persistent wrongdoing at home. We should seek that person’s repentance and recovery, but genuine repentance must be evident in changed behaviour.
We do not know everything that happened
When a marriage ends, other people usually see the outcome rather than the history that led to it.
They may know who left the family home, who sought a divorce or who subsequently entered another relationship. They may know very little about the years of private conduct that preceded those decisions.
A woman may have endured intimidation, sexual coercion, financial control or humiliation for years without anyone outside the home knowing. She may have tried repeatedly to obtain help or preserve the marriage. She may have feared the consequences of disclosing the abuse.
By the time others become aware of the situation, they may see only her departure and the decisions she has made since.
It is easy to judge those decisions with the benefit of hindsight, from a position of relative safety, without knowing the circumstances in which they were made.
Nor does concern for someone’s spiritual welfare give us an unrestricted right to demand an account of everything that happened within their marriage. Ecclesial responsibilities may require us to establish facts, protect vulnerable people and address known wrongdoing. But we have no general entitlement to intimate disclosures simply because we wish to form a judgement.
We can draw reasonable conclusions from conduct we observe. Where someone repeatedly intimidates, humiliates or controls their spouse, that conduct must be taken seriously. Where there is evidence of genuine repentance and sustained change, we should recognise that too.
We do not need to know every detail of a marriage to recognise serious wrongdoing. Equally, knowing some facts does not mean we understand the whole history.
Our judgements should reflect both what we know and what we do not know.
Caring for people when marriages fail
Sometimes a marriage has already suffered terrible damage before the ecclesia becomes aware of it. There may have been years of abuse, separation, divorce or subsequent relationships. The person who suffered abuse may also have made serious mistakes.
For example, a woman who has endured serious abuse may subsequently enter an adulterous relationship. Her husband’s abuse does not make adultery right. She remains responsible before God for her own conduct.
But her adultery does not excuse his abuse, erase what she suffered or remove her need for support.
This is the pastoral concern behind our discussion of 1 Corinthians 7 in Breaking the Cycle. Some have mistaken our application of the passage as an attempt to establish a general permission for divorce or remarriage in circumstances of abuse. Rather, we are interpreting Paul’s teaching through the principle apparent in his recognition that one spouse cannot necessarily preserve a marriage when the other has repudiated its responsibilities, and that God has called us to peace. We believe this principle is relevant where persistent abuse has effectively abandoned the responsibilities of marriage, even without physical departure. Our purpose is to encourage compassion and careful judgement when considering the circumstances of those whose marriages have failed. We may see the decisions they subsequently made without knowing what preceded them, and we have no unrestricted right to demand that they disclose their private experiences. Recognising the principle in Paul’s teaching does not excuse subsequent wrongdoing, but it should make us considerably more cautious about judging people whose circumstances we do not fully understand.
Helping someone repent and recover their relationship with God does not necessarily mean returning them to an abusive spouse.
Separation, divorce and remarriage are distinct questions. A necessary separation for safety does not automatically resolve every question about divorce or a subsequent marriage. These matters require careful scriptural and pastoral consideration.
Where someone has divorced and subsequently remarried, the ecclesia must also consider their present responsibilities, including towards a new spouse and any children. Past wrongdoing may require acknowledgement and repentance, but pastoral care cannot consist solely of condemning decisions that cannot now be undone.
We cannot change the past. We can help people acknowledge what was wrong, take responsibility for what remains within their control, and live faithfully before God from this point.
What should the ecclesia seek to preserve?
When a marriage is in difficulty, our first instinct may be to ask what can be done to keep the couple together.
There is nothing wrong with wanting a marriage to survive. Reconciliation, where it is safe and genuine, is a good outcome.
But keeping people together should not become our overriding measure of success.
We should also ask whether each person is being treated with dignity, whether wrongdoing has been confronted, whether the vulnerable are protected, and whether there is credible evidence of repentance and changed behaviour.
An apology does not automatically restore trust. Forgiveness does not require a person to expose themselves to further harm. Reconciliation requires more than a willingness by the injured spouse to try again.
Where abuse has occurred, those responsible must accept the consequences of their conduct. The person harmed must not be made responsible for producing repentance in the person who harmed them.
There may be circumstances in which the most faithful and compassionate response is to support a separation, even while hoping that genuine repentance and recovery might one day become possible.
There may also be circumstances in which the marriage cannot be restored. The ecclesia’s responsibility to the people involved does not end when the marriage ends.
Valuing marriage by valuing the people within it
We do not honour marriage by preserving its outward appearance while overlooking the suffering of a husband or wife.
We honour it by taking seriously the responsibilities God has placed upon both.
Marriage is intended to be a relationship of faithful love, mutual care and shared discipleship. Its permanence is valuable because it provides the opportunity for that relationship to develop and endure through the changing circumstances of life.
But permanence cannot be treated as a substitute for faithfulness.
The husband and wife are each accountable to God. Each is a person whom Christ calls to discipleship, and neither should be treated as expendable for the sake of maintaining the appearance of an intact marriage.
When we remember that marriage was established for the good of the people within it, we can better understand both why it deserves our commitment and why abuse within it must never be tolerated.
Our commitment to marriage should be demonstrated first in the way we care for the people who have entered it.





Comments